Can At-Home Lashes Ever Look As Natural (And Fluttery) As Salon Lash Extensions? I Tried Both To Find Out

In partnership with Lilac St. Editor’s Note: We only select and work with partners that meet our quality standards, so you can rest assured we only endorse products we believe in.

While I generally consider myself low maintenance, lashes are my thing. For some it’s a fresh spray tan, for others, highlights – but as long as my lashes are looking long and fluttery, I feel unstoppable. Over the years I’ve achieved them a number of ways: I spent my tweens on the hunt for the most dramatic mascara I could find, perfected the falsies application in college, and became a regular at my local salon once the disposable income kicked in. And then I got busy. 

When making the time – and shelling out the cash – for salon lash extensions became a chore, I was curious to find something that looked as good (because let’s be honest, salon-quality lashes look good) but didn’t require so much effort. After many hours sifting through Reddit recommendations, I emerged with one obvious fan-favorite: Lilac St. Here I’m putting the brand to the test against salon lash extensions. Welcome to another throwdown: at-home lash extensions vs. the lash salon experience. 

We like

We don't like

Application/Convenience 

Salon: While getting my lashes done at the salon doesn’t require much effort-wise from me (I am paying someone so I just have to lie there), I find the hour spent in the salon excruciating, mainly because the technician gently tapes my eyes shut as she applies extensions to each real lash – and that freaks me out. I understand that the intricacy of this is what makes the final result look so natural (and, of course, there are much worse fates to endure) but I swear time slows down when I’m there. On top of that, finding the time to schedule an appointment and stay on top of my #lashgame gets old. 

At-home: Applying extensions at home is more labor-intensive for me, but now that I have the hang of it (it took several tries to get here), it’s a quick ten minute activity. Lilac St. sent me everything I needed in the Deluxe Starter Kit, so all I have to do is: clean my lashes, apply the glue, adhere the lashes to my waterline (this part is important – and different from falsies), then fuse and seal them. Whatever frustration you’re envisioning – cut it in half. This application is shockingly do-able with all of the tips and tricks and accouterments that come with the kit – and I love being able to do it on my own time (and quickly!).

Winner: At-home

All the tools I need!

Longevity/Maintenance

Salon: On average, my salon lashes would last me about a month. Caring for them included avoiding water for the first couple of days after application (not ideal) and generally avoiding oil-based products. Other than that, I could do pretty much anything in them without worrying. I do want to note that over time, I noticed my natural lashes thinning out a good bit. This started a tricky cycle of wanting to continue getting extensions to make up for my lack of lashes…but also knowing that the extensions were causing this thinning. Another issue I had was in the days leading up to my fill appointment – I hate the look of having a few missing lashes, which would sometimes happen if I wasn’t super on top of my booking game, or if I was waiting for a certain day to book so I’d look my freshest for a big event (cosmetic girl math is not for the faint of heart). 

At-home: Lilac St. lashes last me a good ten days upon application, so they definitely don’t last as long as salon lashes. In those ten days, though, I really don’t hold  back: I swim, run, and sleep in them with no problems (after a few trials that did require some zhuzhing to my left-most lashes when I woke up in the morning). As with salon lashes, it’s recommended to be gentle when washing your makeup off, especially if you use an oil-based cleaner. With Lilac St., I like that I have control over when I take these lashes off – and while we’re on the topic, removing them is simple and gentle with the brand’s oil-based remover. It’s nice to have a level of control over my schedule where I’m not so dependent on an esthetician and perfectly-thought-out schedule to achieve the look I’m going for.

Winner: Tie (depends on your priorities)

I love how natural these look!

Appearance

Salon: We all know professionally-applied lashes look gorgeous, flawless, stunning – all the good things. My main curiosity was if at-home lashes could come anywhere close to this gorgeousness (my expectations were admittedly low). 

At-home: I’ll let the photos do most of the talking here. There’s not a ton I can say to capture how floored I am every time I look in the mirror and realize I accomplished this…by myself? I get compliments all the time (not to brag but 💅), and I can’t count the number of jaws I’ve seen drop when I tell them they’re at home lash extensions. Reddit was right – these lashes really do look professionally-applied when done properly. 

Winner: Tie (and that’s a BFD!)

Look at the difference!

Cost

Salon: I knew I was spending a lot of money on my salon lashes – and I was honestly okay with it – but now that I’m not, I find these numbers a little quease-inducing: my initial set cost $250, and then I paid ~$100/month for a fill. 

At-home: Here’s where things really get good. The Deluxe Starter Kit is $65 ($65!!), and each set of lashes costs $11. I am saving so much money doing my own lashes – and no one (myself included if I’m being honest) can tell the difference. 

Winner: At-home

Overall winner: Lilac St.’s at-home lashes. Use code TQE15 for 15% off!

I loved this throwdown because it was probably my most-shocking to date. I expected to like Lilac St. for emergency moments – when I had a last-minute event, or to hold me over between lash appointments, but I had no clue I’d become a full blown devotee! As a self-proclaimed not DIY girlie, I couldn’t have imagined how seamless the application experience would be – nor the stunning results. If you have ever the slightest bit of interest in trying at-home lashes…do it!! And start with Lilac St.

No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.

Shop The Edit

No items found.

Additional Reading

No items found.